WHAT IS INTELLIGENCE, ANYWAY?
Isaac
Asimov, USA (1920-1992)
In this argumentative
essay, the writer makes an argument that intelligence is not absolute but is a
function of society. Often, we define intelligence with respect to human
qualities. Thus, as we tend to consider ourselves as the most intelligent
species, we compare other species to ourselves. Yet, is this really
possible?
"We willingly accept
the idea of intelligence in a life form only if the intelligence displayed is
on the same evolutionary wavelength as our own. The technology automatically
indicates intelligence. An absence of technology translates into an absence of
intelligence."
Truly, intelligence seems
to be relative; it evolves to fulfill the needs of a particular species. How,
then, can we truly compare the intelligence of a crocodile with that of a whale
or that of a human? Evolutionarily speaking, scientists agree that organisms seem
to have become more complex behaviorally. Some argue that this is correlated
with increased brain size. Changes to the brain have occurred in specific
structures.
“What is intelligence anyway?”
Intelligence is a
subjective matter. A person intelligent in one field may be a loggerhead (a
stupid person) in another field. It may be possible that a person is
intelligent in two or more fields, but he/she will still be lagging behind in the other
field. Hence, we can’t term the person as intelligent in general. For example,
a good teacher might be a bad student and vice versa. A good administrator may
be a bad father. Hence, a person is intelligent in administration but bad with
family.
Asimov also focuses on
the fact that intelligence is the outcome of experience and knowledge. Asimov
is intelligent in study and literature, but he is not intelligent enough to maintain
his car. His automobile repairman is far more intelligent in this field than he is. But on the other hand, Asimov is far more intelligent in study and
literature than his automobile repairman. Hence, we understand that intelligence
is a subjective matter. Any person cannot be intelligent in general. It depends
on the particular field of concern.
Summary:
“What Is Intelligence,
Anyway?” is an article that is written by Isaac Asimov. He is a Russian who
grew up in America. Being well-educated, he received his PhD in chemistry from
Columbia University. He is known as a writer for all types of readers, from
specialized to non-specialized. Based on his articles, Dr. Asimov is considered
to be the most intelligent. Isaac Asimov writes about how he has always scored
high on academic tests. He scored 160 when the average score was 100, and there were people who made a big fuss (worry unnecessarily / excessively)
over that. And that the auto repairman didn't seem as intelligent as he was, but would always fix his car. Then he says that if the auto repair guy asked him questions for an intelligence test, he would fail it and would look
like a moron (idiot/a person of subnormal intelligence).
When Asimov was in the
army, he took part in IQ tests and scored 160, much above the norm. Looking
at such an achievement, he used to think that he was very intelligent. But he was
less intelligent in other fields like mechanics and domestic work. For
example, when his car broke down, he could not repair it on his own and had to get
help from the mechanics. According to the writer, intelligence can never be
determined by only one dimension. Even great scholars and academicians can
be proven to be foolish in the fields where their academic training does not
work. He thinks that one's intelligence is not absolute or universal; rather, it is designed by the function of society.
As we are reading through
his introduction about how intelligent he is, we think that this man is too
proud. But as we continue reading the article, we find that he slowly
recognizes his intelligence does not apply to every aspect of his life. Dr.
Asimov talks about his auto repairman, who would never have a score of 80 on
this intelligence test if he took it. However, the car is always fixed every
time Dr. Asimov brings it to the auto repairman. In the middle of the article,
Dr. Asimov says that he is an intelligent man wherever he can use his
academic training and his verbal talents, but when it comes to doing something
intricate (complex) or hard, working with his hands, then he would be a “moron.”
One thing that we like
the most about Dr. Asimov is that he is not embarrassed to tell people how he
got tricked by an auto repairman who could not even score 80 on the
intelligence test.





